When holiday enthusiast Addie (Cindy Sampson) makes a Christmas wish for her next-door neighbor Sam (Robin Dunne) to fall in love with her, she is not expecting anything–and certainly not that the desire will go haywire and force her other neighbor, Pete (Chris Violette), to fall in love instead. Addie enlists Sam's assistance as Pete's amorous gestures become increasingly extravagant. Can Addie end the spell before Christmas with Sam's assistance? Or will she be doomed to spend the remainder of her years dealing with a lovelorn Pete?